Long Island was already on the list - media makes enough references, that we can't not go there :P

I'd suggest you check out Colonial Williamsburg

Ooh! Thanks! That definitely sounds good. And Cape Cod. See, this is exactly our problem. So much to choose from, it's hard to even know where to start looking. Distances really are problematic. At the end of the day, we won't even know how fast we'll be moving until we're actually there. I want to go far enough south to see alligators, but so far it's a three-against-one vote, so we'll see what happens. :P